What a great round-table topic; I think you guys covered it pretty solid! Hopefully more people have more examples of what needs to have co-op, or what shouldn't. I don't think I have much more to contribute (the Spider-man Web of Shadows co-op comment I completely agree with, more than most of the titles!)

 

Great discussion, although I think it was a bit short. I agree with the comments of games base don teams (squads) should have co-op since the property is revolving around a cooperative setting.

Great job!

I would like to add that I feel Farcry 2 deserved co-op because of the open-world design and the fact that any merc model you do not choose to play as in the beginning becomes character you interact with later.