Log In




Forgot your password?

On The Download Issue 16: How to choose, XBLA/PSN/PC?

Editorial
Twitter facebook googlebuzz

It’s been a long-running battle of fans based on a lot of nonsense and personal preference, but how do you choose which system to buy a game on? Content available? Support? Online connectivity? Or are you one that consults all of your friends before coming to a decision on which system to use?

I for one fall in the final category, often texting, emailing, or messaging many friends before settling on a system based on who I want to play what with. Here are a few of my own examples.

A few months ago I had some friends discussing retro-gaming. One game in particular - well, actually it’s technically two games, came up in the conversation. Final Fight: Double Impact which featured both Final Fight and Magic Sword. The conversation went a little like this:

Me: “I miss old school brawlers. The ones in the arcades, you know?”
My buddy: “Well, there is that Final Fight game coming out soon, it’s got two of those games all remastered.”
Me: “If it’s online, we should definitely play!”
My buddy: “Man, those were my favorite games growing up. It would be so great to co-op. I only have PSN though...”
Me: “I guess that settles it, PSN version it is.”

He and I then played hours of Double Impact, reminiscing about the good old days, using old secrets from the old game, etc. In spite of his PSN requirement, I did have a choice in which system I liked to use. To be honest, I generally choose XBLA because of the number of my friends that play that way - but it’s really a whole lot of things to consider if you really think about it.

In fact, a few of my friends recently had a similar dilemma with Shank. Today it was released on the PSN, and tomorrow it hits Xbox Live. The thought here became: do we all wait and play together, or some of us branch off to tackle the PSN version while the others have to wait for the XBLA to drop?

If you throw in PC game options, then you get quite the love-hate triangle going. Some fortunate people may just buy several copies of a game to play with all of their friends, while the rest of us have to pick and choose. When have you had to make a similar decision about a downloadable game? Was the co-op your deciding factor, too?

New in Download and DLC:

Deathspank: Thongs of Virtue will be following up the highly successful, though somewhat co-op insufficient Deathspank. Yea, that’s right, already. It’s been a month since Deathspank rocked us, and he’s already back for round two - not that I’m complaining, mind you.

In DLC news, both Left 4 Dead and Left 4 Dead 2 will be getting a new DLC pack titled The Sacrifice. It’s nice to see Valve keep taking care of their fans, even the ones that didn’t but both versions of their games. Crackdown 2 is also going to be playing the DLC game with a free pack, and a premium DLC pack. In these packs includes new Agent suit colors, new vehicles, and new achievement challenges for all to enjoy.

Free for You:

Because a lot of people really pushed this in my last On the Download, I’ll give the Pixel Junk games a little love. Each of the games has local co-op in the PSN demo, and they include: Pixel Junk Monsters Deluxe, Pixel Junk Shooter, and Pixel Junk Eden. Check ‘em out for free, yo.

 
Reads: 2837
 

Related Stories




SecretAsianManz
11:18 PM
8/24/2010

Good editorial. It's a question I've often asked myself in the past. For me, it's a mix of factors. Number one is who else I know has it/is getting it and what system they're getting it on. If it's pretty much a tie, then I consider what type of game it is. Usually, if visuals are a significant factor, I'll go with PS3, although Xbox Live is a much better system for getting together. I love Steam as well, but I only play certain types of games on PC, namely shooters and RPGs. If community content is an option, then it's usually best on the PC. In the end I guess I don't really have a good answer.


hedgehogaj
11:09 AM
8/25/2010

The friends I play with usually all have the same options I do, so unless one of them picked it up first, we just debate what system to get it for.

Generally I go for PSN if possible. Most "arcade" style games I play weren't meant for an analog stick, and the PS3 has a functional D-pad. My PS3 also has a lot more drive space.


BigBadBob113
5:32 PM
8/25/2010

Nice article. Now that I have a PS3 and 360, I find myself facing the same problems. I was asking myself this very question in regards to Scott Pilgrim, but since neither version has online play, I still don't know which one to go for. However, for me it's not just downloadable games, but disc-based games as well. A prime example is that my next purchase is going to be WWE Smackdown vs. Raw 2011 (already traded in some games to Amazon so I can pre-order it), but I find myself asking which system I will be getting it on.

One of my biggest deciding factors is online play, since there is very little local play at my place. So if a version of a game had online play where another didn't, or had a better, more-active online community, then that's the way I would go.


Shazoo
5:55 PM
8/25/2010

well exclusives I get on the system they're out on, but for the multi console releases I tend to fall into some of the same mentioned answers.

1. Am I going to play it online (if available), if so then how many friends are getting it, usually go with that console.
2. Do the consoles differ in quality, is one a port of the other? Read reviews to see which is less buggy, go with that version.
3. Do versions differ in content (ie unreal tournament 3), go with better version.


MisterDeeth
10:48 AM
8/27/2010

My list of criteria is pretty similar to Shazoo's. I try to get most of them on PSN, however. Most of the folks I know have the same console options and choose PSN every time.

Login to Comment

Forgot your password?

Register

CoG UserName:
CoG Password:

Login or Register for Co-Optimus to meet other co-op gamers, comment on articles, and create and post your own blog. You can even use your Facebook account to quickly create a Co-Optimus account and login with one click. You may also use your Colony of Gamers account to comment.

Total Comments: 5

UPCOMING CO-OP RELEASE DATES

Fuse(360,PS3)05.28.2013
CastleStorm(XBLA)05.29.2013
Painkiller Hell & Damnation(360,PS3)05.31.2013
 Visit our Full Co-Op Release Calendar

INTERESTING ARTICLES AROUND THE WEB