Login or Register

Forgot your username?

Forgot your password?

Red Dead Redemption Co-Op Review

Review
Twitter facebook googlebuzz

There's plenty of meat to be had in the single player portion of the game, which can take anywhere from 15 to 30 hours to complete depending on how easily distracted you are. Moving on from there is the game's multiplayer mode called Free Roam. This open world allows 16 players to join in and do just about whatever they want. The goal of it though is to posse up and then move on to other multiplayer modes - like some of the versus ones found within the game. This happens fairly seamlessly, but if you choose, you can roam around the entire map with your posse and complete a few challenges together in co-op.

Available for you and your crew of eight posse members are bandit hideouts located throughout the map. The goal is pretty straightforward - kill all the bandits and get out alive. Certain hideouts have you moving a mine cart out to a carriage waiting for you. After completing these players can work on challenges to unlock more characters and items for their multiplayer level. While each player still has to complete the goals of the challenge for credit, there is some teamwork involved with finding certain items or killing a set number of animals.

It really didn't take long for us to clear all the bandit forts, a few hours at most - but somehow we managed to find ourself playing for over three hours at a time doing god knows what in the old west. To be honest, it has a bit of that Crackdown flaire to it, that invisible thing you can't quite put your finger on what's exactly so fun. It's an absolute blast when you have a stage coach full of your friends riding over the desert to assault a bandit compound only to drive it straight off a cliff...and survive. It's these "had to be there" moments that make Red Dead Redemption's co-op more fun than it should be.

That being said the co-op is a bit disappointing, as the potential is there for a seriously good time in the old west.  A few extra little touches like the ability to play poker or some of the other mini-games with friends could add to the immersion, and we've yet to see a game that allows a co-op group to take on a train robbery. Please make this happen Rockstar - as it stands now -the train is completely missing in Free Roam. This is why we are really looking forward to the upcoming DLC with missions designed exclusively for co-op, once this hits, we'll revisit this review and adjust accordingly.

On the whole Red Dead Redemption is the finest western game created to date - the sum of all it's parts add up to an amazing experience. There's a few quirks along the way including technical bugs, multiplayer connection issues, and some minor control gripes - but these hardly bring down the entire set. While the co-op mode is quite open ended with only a handful of things to do, it's still a ton of fun, and the single player content is substantial. Rockstar Games once again proves to be the king of open world titles, this time in a completely open and compelling Western world.

The Co-Op Experience: Form a gang with up to 8 members and take out bandit hideouts, complete challenges and ride around the countryside together.

Co-Op Score: 3 out of 5
General Score: 4.5 out of 5


Co-Optimus game reviews focus on the cooperative experience of a game, our final score graphic represents this experience. Our General Score is more representitive of the overall experience.



Reads: 13473
 
Share:
Twitter facebook googlebuzz email

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Stories



Reader Comments - Follow this discussion on the forums!


Zonf86
9:03 AM
5/28/2010

So much potential for a great co-op experience.


Dr0kz
9:16 AM
5/28/2010

Color me excited, this seems like the most fun we are going to have in years with clothes on.


TheReaperCooL
9:46 AM
5/28/2010

I already played this in Co-op System Link, and it's a blast!


Biohzrd451
9:53 AM
5/28/2010

--- Replying to Dr0kz -----


Now whats saying most of us game with clothes on?


Syphous
10:13 AM
5/28/2010

I have this game and love it. However the freeroam gets real boring real fast. After you've completed the bandit's hideouts, all you can do is.. do them again. The co-op DLC that's coming out in a few weeks should help a lot.


Parflagush
10:38 AM
5/28/2010

Played co-op for about 6 hours with my buds. It's true, there isn't much content to keep your posse entertained after you do the hideouts over and over. But as pointed out in the review, you kind of have to make your own fun if you want to keep going for now. Can't wait for DLC!


txshurricane
12:15 PM
5/28/2010

Nick, I agree with your assessment. The Free Roam suffers - oh, there's plenty to do, but it takes ingenuity. Most of the time, random pubbies would rather kill you out of boredom.


HobocidalManiac
12:16 PM
5/28/2010

Is there going to be another review when the co-op DLC comes out? They're adding in a handful of missions for my favorite price: FREE.


Bakken Hood
12:31 PM
5/28/2010

The connection issues are frustrating indeed. I haven't seen so many party drops outside of ODST. I'm not crazy about the interface, either, what with how many buttons I have to push to request a posse invite and how I have to drop out of the posse to ditch my f@#king mule for a real horse after leveling up. Still, when it works, it's a blast. Shooting bandits in a lovely desert canyon is somehow more awesomer than shooting aliens or terrorists. I'm sure I'll get sick of the hideouts, especially since they're pretty much the same as the single player versions except you have seven other jerkwads stealing all your frickin' kills (I kid, I kid), but I'm eagerly looking forward to the co-op DLC.


txshurricane
1:30 PM
5/28/2010

--- Replying to HobocidalManiac -----
I can't speak for Nick, but probably not. There will probably just be an added page with impressions.


HobocidalManiac
1:55 PM
5/28/2010

--- Replying to txshurricane -----
It just seems a bit unfair to review a game for it's lacking co-op when they announced before the game was released that they're adding in free co-op DLC a month from release. It's not entirely an optional thing like paid DLC, so I think it should be considered in the score.


bapenguin
2:00 PM
5/28/2010

Yes, I'm going to append the review with new co-op stuff once available. Not sure about changing the score - but I might do some trickery. We'll see, it depends how it's implemented.


HobocidalManiac
2:08 PM
5/28/2010

--- Replying to bapenguin -----
Awesome. I don't want this game getting a bad review. I know it's a co-op focused site, but this game is an amazing single player experience and I don't want the score driving people away.


JoeyMojo
3:42 PM
5/28/2010

Honestly, as a co-op game, I'd have to rate this at 2, at best. Riding around as a posse taking out bandits the first time is fun. the 2nd time you take out the *same* six bandit hideouts, the *same* way, it gets tedious. 75% of the great things that make the single-player sandbox experience so compelling are completely absent. I enjoy RDR, but it's a good single-player and multi-player competitive game. As a cooperative title, it stinks.


bapenguin
3:48 PM
5/28/2010

I was leaning towards a 2.5 in the score, but it's all arbitrary really. For me I did complete runs of all bandit hideouts with two separate groups and enjoyed it equally both times. There's a lot of intangible fun to be had IMO which is why I inched things up.

But you are right, you shouldn't buy this game for the co-op alone.


Willtur
4:12 PM
5/28/2010

I am contemplating buying this but I dont play single player games at all these days, So you said about 2 hours of co-op against AI? I am just wondering if it's for me because I dont do anything but co-op.


bapenguin
6:43 PM
5/28/2010

Like I said Willtur - right now - can't recommend it just for co-op unless you are a hardcore western fan. Once the free DLC releases, I might feel differently.


moui
8:56 PM
5/28/2010

Chiming in to also say that the co-op which is currently available is not worth a purchase if that's all you're looking for. I really don't find it interesting at all, beyond the first run through.

The single player is great, though.


Arionel
2:35 AM
5/29/2010

This game has provoked my thoughts that a title like this would might suceed more if there was a co-op campaign or goodness cuz I play 'em too...a MMORPG along this vein.


bigtex
4:45 PM
5/29/2010

I'm not sure if I played the wrong game, but this game deserves maybe a 1 for coop. There's almost nothing to do, there's no point in money for coop, there are no vendors/NPCs, as they're all taken out. The only thing you do is roam around until you come across one of a few sparse camps.

This game may be awesome for the Single Player or Death match crowd, but I was duped into thinking it had something to do in coop. All of the animals we hunted die in 1 shot, it's not actually hunting. It's random killing an animal you see.

The game also looks beautiful, but it's just not fun in coop. The coop is more something for people to 'do' while they wait for deathmatch games.

This site is 'cooptimus', and the review is for coop, this game deserves a 1 at most for the coop experience.

Anyone buying/renting this as my friends and I did, for Coop Only, will be severely bored and disappointed.


grommyfrog
5:34 PM
5/29/2010

The most fun I've had with the online mode is to get everyone in the posse with a "Wanted" level. We just pick a town to shoot up and try to stay alive. It turns the Free Play mode into a make shift Horde/Survival game mode.

Not much else to do.


bapenguin
1:39 PM
5/30/2010

There's plenty to do in co-op bigtex - like I said, it's one of those things that you just make of it as you will. There's no "structure" to the co-op at hand.

The money is used for your character experience, which levels you up and unlocks stuff for all multiplayer modes.

We were hunting bears at one point and they definitely don't take just one shot.

Like I said, I've played about 6 hours of co-op and both times I greatly enjoyed myself. Perhaps I'm just entertained easier.


bapenguin
1:41 PM
5/30/2010

--- Replying to grommyfrog -----

I think this is kind of the beauty of it though. Creating those intangible experiences using what the developers gave you. That's a great idea!

Login to Comment

Forgot your password?

Register

CoG UserName:
CoG Password:

Login or Register for Co-Optimus to meet other co-op gamers, comment on articles, and create and post your own blog. You can even use your Facebook account to quickly create a Co-Optimus account and login with one click. You may also use your Colony of Gamers account to comment.

Total Comments: 23

ADVERTISEMENT

INTERESTING ARTICLES AROUND THE WEB